Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
Memory Lane by I-am-knot Memory Lane by I-am-knot
READ THIS --> As many have pointed out, I know "she wont out live her friends". I know that the writers have said that. But is that really such a big deal when watching fan work? If you do think so, please keep it to yourself, I've already heard every version of disagreement now.

Twilight "only" thanks Pinkie because when the filly is offering to give away her balloons to cheer up the princess. And when saying "Thanks you" to the filly, Twilight is reminded of Pinkie Pie in that specific moment and thus uses her name.

I didn't forget Rainbow Dash. She is represented by the prism in panel three.

Inspired by :iconagamnentzar: :icontim015: browse.deviantart.com/art/The-…

We have reached that point again where there are just too many comment for me to answer. I have read everyone and I'm thankful for them. Even if I didn't reply.
Add a Comment:
 
:iconcadenske:
Critique by Cadenske Dec 28, 2013, 11:34:45 PM
I had to give everything full stars, as it actually had a tear run down my eye. This is true to being alicorn, you outlive your normal friends, and the representation to this picture really gives in some thought that Twilight is nearly forever, forever to have memories of her dead friends.
Thank you for making this, it's truly a beautiful piece of art and meaning, it even shows Twilight's adjustment to her crown and armor. Her expression is very Twilight, you can see the emotion in her eyes.
Too bad, we all know this is bound to happen. Amazing artwork.
~Cadenske
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
115 out of 121 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconjarlballin:
It took me a second to figure out what was going on in this one, but after I had it sorted out it almost made me shed tears. It's kinda sad that alicorns will outlive the other pony types, but I'd rather not think about it because I dont want Twilight to be alone. Since I'm a huge fan of Twilight myself, I think it's no wonder that this piece of work affects my feeligns in a way.
Anyways, this is a beautiful work of art with a meaning to it.
I really like the art style and the story this one tells.

-JarlBallin
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
69 out of 72 deviants thought this was fair.

The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork

Please sign up or login to post a critique.

:iconatomicrockx:
AtomicrockX Featured By Owner 1 day ago
Relax, there is nothing to worry, this will not happen, as a friend he read by Twitter of some of the people who work in the series (including Meghan McCarthy) have said very clearly that no immortality it will go into Twilight and she will never leave her friends.
Reply
:iconmagical-midget-horse:
When did the writers say that?
Been so off from the fandom for a while now that I didn't know about what the writers said about twilicorn.
Reply
:iconmrhistorybuff:
mrhistorybuff Featured By Owner Jul 12, 2015
I clicked on the link to your friends art I am knot and I'm kind of depressed and heartbroken now it's sad I mean there beautiful picture(s) dont get me wrong - but why do they have to be sad :( :( :( :( :(
Reply
:iconi-am-knot:
I-am-knot Featured By Owner Jul 18, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Sometimes you're just sad. It's no biggie.
Reply
:iconsleepystarspider:
sleepystarspider Featured By Owner Jul 6, 2015  New Deviant
Until it's established in show, there's no guarantee the writers will keep their words.
Reply
:iconmrhistorybuff:
mrhistorybuff Featured By Owner Jul 12, 2015
When and where did the writers say this....... link ........are the entire main six immortal now cuz that'd be so awesome!!!!!!!!!!! # :D a question what started the trend of boys liking MLP I can't explain exactly why I like it I just do does anyone here have any theories :D?¿ ♡♡♡♡♡
Reply
:iconsleepystarspider:
sleepystarspider Featured By Owner Jul 13, 2015  New Deviant
www.equestriadaily.com/2013/04…

It was an issue since Faust presented the two Alicorn sisters as immortals or at least increadably longed lived, that left folks assuming that was part and parcel of being an Alicorn.  Hasbro then forced Cadence to be upgraded to Alicorn and by the Time Twi got the upgrade Faust had packed her bags. Folks were making assumptions that the newly minted Alicorns would have similarly long lives since that was Faust's original presentation.

Recently, there was a book, not comic, that indicated the process of moving the Sun and Moon rejuvenate  Celestia and Luna, which sounds like that's going to be the canon reason the Sisters live so long.
Reply
:iconmrhistorybuff:
mrhistorybuff Featured By Owner Jul 13, 2015
But wasint cadence already a alicorn who made the book and yyyy did Lauren Faust leave the show which episode what season and why#??????
Reply
:iconsleepystarspider:
sleepystarspider Featured By Owner Jul 13, 2015  New Deviant
mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Princess_Ca…

Faust developed and wrote for season 1 and consulted for season 2.

Why she left? LOTS of creative people who work for hire, eventually realize what they though was their creation doesn't actually belong to them, that the owners ARE going to get what they want even if that means tearing asunder everything the artist stood for. That final realization often leads to folks separating from the property.  Heck I'd bet Cadence being a Pink Alicorn Princess who's first role was to be rescued so she could be married was what was the last straw.
Reply
:iconmrhistorybuff:
mrhistorybuff Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2015
Woh ok but how much difference does this make y was faust so upset how many different things were there between the show she had and the show we have now and btw I actually liked eqg
Reply
:iconsleepystarspider:
sleepystarspider Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2015  New Deviant
Well, if I had to ( figuratively) crawl into Faust's brain, I'd say the biggest issue was she probably felt all the work she had done to make MLP successful among a broader audience was was being thrown back in her face by the studio.
Reply
:iconmrhistorybuff:
mrhistorybuff Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2015
Oh you mean like what got like um boys too like the show for instance what did get boys to like the show anyway I'm a guy and I like the show but I don't know what got me to like it but whatever it was I'm glad it did♡^>^♡
Reply
:iconcookie-fish:
Cookie-fish Featured By Owner Jun 17, 2015  Student General Artist
Oh my, the feels.
Reply
:iconmrhistorybuff:
mrhistorybuff Featured By Owner Jun 8, 2015
Same here I also feel sad author of this post the picture I mean when when u say she won't out live friends does that mean they're all the immortal now is that what the writers meant??!!!
Reply
:iconspringtraptrap3:
SpringtrapTrap3 Featured By Owner May 28, 2015
that make me feel sad
Reply
:iconf-o-reign:
F-o-reign Featured By Owner May 12, 2015
Danisnotonfire: FEELS  Danisnotonfire: FEELS  Danisnotonfire: FEELS 
Reply
:icon79089:
79089 Featured By Owner Apr 14, 2015  Hobbyist Artist
OMG THE FEELS!
Reply
:icondreadmaster231:
Dreadmaster231 Featured By Owner Apr 13, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
The one flaw for immortality...

That's why when you wish for it, you ask for liquid duplicates to give to your friends.
Reply
:iconjaruskais:
JarusKais Featured By Owner Apr 13, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
:iconlikebuttonplz:
Reply
:iconeva-janova:
Eva-Janova Featured By Owner Apr 9, 2015
I totally agree! This work is wonderful! I have so many ideas about if twilight outlived the others! But was so afraid to try! I think I might attempt it now! Thank you! For the inspiration!
Reply
:iconi-am-knot:
I-am-knot Featured By Owner Apr 9, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
The chain of inspiration grows! That's great. Best of luck, friend!
Reply
:iconglitch-sketch:
Glitch-Sketch Featured By Owner Apr 8, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
...damnit, this made me so sad...
Reply
:iconzombiefx:
ZombieFX Featured By Owner Feb 21, 2015
Immortality is a curse, not a gift.
Reply
:iconturkey18eye:
turkey18eye Featured By Owner Edited Feb 26, 2015
answer this question:
IF YOU BECOME IMMORTALL THEN YOU DON'T HAVE TO FEAR DEATH AND YOU BECOME BEAUTIFULL/HANDSOME FOREVER,WOULD YOU WANT THIS OR STAY AS MORTAL SO YOU CAN GROW OLD DIED WITH YOUR FRIEND AND FAMILY CHOOSE WISELY
what is your answer=
Reply
:iconmonkeyrofl901:
Monkeyrofl901 Featured By Owner Apr 4, 2015
I'd stay mortal, because I have no looks to preserve and I don't fear death.
Reply
:iconzombiefx:
ZombieFX Featured By Owner Mar 13, 2015
Well, immortality doesn't necessary mean you live forever... (violent death).

I think until i found my special somepony i would chose mortality... 
since i know that i might lose friends... but i also will meet new ones on the journey.

Death is quiet common in my family... but that's an important part of life.
Reply
:iconturkey18eye:
turkey18eye Featured By Owner Mar 15, 2015
thank q for sharing your thought
Reply
:iconzombiefx:
ZombieFX Featured By Owner Mar 20, 2015
you are welcome. life long and prosper :)
Reply
:iconoolimenoteoo:
OolimenoteoO Featured By Owner Mar 8, 2015
1 we dont fear death it is a wish so you  wont have to keep on doing what your doing now 1who cares to be butiful or handsom forever 3.Probley choose with your friends and family to meet them up in heven
Reply
:iconturkey18eye:
turkey18eye Featured By Owner Mar 12, 2015
word of advice
1:you should read your typing first before you post,it confusing???
p.s good choose
Reply
:iconoolimenoteoo:
OolimenoteoO Featured By Owner Mar 12, 2015
dude im deslexic PEOPLE LIKE YOU DISGUST ME
Reply
:icongerbsterpers:
Gerbsterpers Featured By Owner Feb 10, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Da feeeeeeeeeeeeeeeels
I'm drowning in them noooooooooooooooo
Awesome job!
Even if you basically killed me inside!
Reply
:iconi-am-knot:
I-am-knot Featured By Owner Feb 10, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Inside killing is best killing?
Reply
:icongerbsterpers:
Gerbsterpers Featured By Owner Feb 11, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Maybe
Maaaaaybe
Reply
:iconsarahthekiller1:
SarahTheKiller1 Featured By Owner Jan 31, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
There goes the feels
Reply
:iconsantana642:
Santana642 Featured By Owner Jan 31, 2015  Student General Artist
This was very wel done :D
Reply
:iconilovecelestiaalot:
ilovecelestiaalot Featured By Owner Jan 31, 2015
gaahh them feels...  Cry forever 
Reply
:iconfrostsentry150:
FrostSentry150 Featured By Owner Jan 30, 2015  Student Digital Artist
ow ; - ;
Reply
:iconclockworkcatastroph3:
ClockworkCatastroph3 Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Honestly why wouldn't she outlive her friends if she's an Alicorn?  
Reply
:iconjardape:
jardape Featured By Owner Jan 30, 2015
And we mustn't forget that all are elements of harmony and that makes them ageless.
Reply
:iconi-am-knot:
I-am-knot Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I think the reason they said she wouldn't is because the show will never deal with the issue. I mean, however popular it gets. It won't last 50+ years. And we wont have to know what happens when a pony gets really old. I don't even think granny smith will ever die in the show.
Reply
:iconclockworkcatastroph3:
ClockworkCatastroph3 Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Today's cartoons just seem to tiptoe around these subjects anymore.  
Reply
:iconjmk-prime:
JMK-Prime Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Student General Artist
Waaaah! Beautiful.
Reply
:icongalactic-beaver:
Galactic-Beaver Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
The only thing I'm kind of tiffed about is that she isn't taller or made to look older. I doubt Celestia was always that tall.
Reply
:iconyakshi7:
Yakshi7 Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015
Well ain't that just a punch to the gut...
I kinda feel sory for Twilight if that's supposed to be her future.
Reply
:iconi-am-knot:
I-am-knot Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
There's probably good aspects of her life to.
Reply
:icondefinitelyn0t:
DefinitelyN0t Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015
HNNNNNG, right in the feels...
Reply
:iconkrazzulimaii:
Krazzulimaii Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Whoa, 714 comments?!

But this is a good comic. Even though the writers said this or that, I think this is a fantastic comic depicting what could've been.
Reply
:iconi-am-knot:
I-am-knot Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Thank you very much!

And yeah it's a ton of comments. I haven't been able to reply to them all.
Reply
:iconibrahim77x:
Ibrahim77x Featured By Owner Edited Jan 29, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
And Spike? Where's he?
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×
Download PNG 1238 × 3991




Details

Submitted on
June 3, 2013
Image Size
18.9 MB
Resolution
1238×3991
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
97,745 (3 today)
Favourites
3,871 (who?)
Comments
771
Downloads
628
×